#2 Johnny Gargano
Why Johnny Gargano? Because there's no-one in the WWE right now who is as much of a white hot good guy as Johnny Gargano was (we're going to ignore the last couple of weeks of Johnny Failure...).
And who better to play Superman than the person who literally everyone in the WWE Universe wants to see succeed and overcome that dastardly Tommaso Ciampa? In fact, Gargano already has an arch-nemesis Lex Luthor in Ciampa, so he has experience at this kind of thing!
Edited by Anthony Akatugba Jr.