#2 Not Deserving- Randy Orton
Randy Orton is the youngest two time World champion in the company's history and will always have a great place in the WWE in the time to come. He along with Cena were the flagbearers for the company in the past decade.
He has been largely successful as a vicious heel and as a babyface, he was good but not as convincing as when he is in the darker side.
Even his recent feud with a fellow great Jeff Hardy was great because it projected Randy as a villain who brought back his old mannerisms which made him a star that he is now.
Orton is still only 38 but already past his prime to be a world champion. He can put over various superstars like Jericho used to do. He can elevate the mid-card and tag team titles.