#1 Enzo Amore: Didn't Handle It Well
Enzo Amore was one of the most popular stars in the WWE roster, being one of the highest merchandise sellers. Week after week, people chanted along with his catchphrases and he seemed like a long-term player for WWE.
He was moved to the Cruiserweight Division and then won the title in quick order, sending the division into a dark period. Soon after, he was accused of rape by a girl from Phoenix and was released with immediate effect after he reportedly never informed WWE that he was being investigated.
It was clear that the accusations didn't have much base to them and he was soon proven innocent. He came out of silence after this and went on to release two rap videos under a different name - 'Real 1".
These videos didn't help Amore's cause at all and it only further soured him in the eyes of the people. He vowed not to return to wrestling again.