#1 Mordecai
Soon after WrestleMania 20 in 2004, WWE began airing vignettes, teasing the arrival of Mordecai. The sinister entity was a religious zealot character, and he claimed in his promos that he would rid the world of sin. Mordecai made his WWE debut at the Judgment Day PPV, swiftly defeating Scotty 2 Hotty. He went on to condemn the WWE Universe for committing sins and led the audience in prayer on several occasions.
Mordecai started a rivalry with Hardcore Holly soon after and defeated him at The Great American Bash PPV. He lost to Rey Mysterio on the following episode of SmackDown and was never heard of again. In reality, Kevin Fertig had engaged in a bar fight, and Vince McMahon wasn't happy at what had happened. Mordecai was never mentioned again on TV. He was slated to kick off a feud with The Undertaker on the road to WrestleMania 21, culminating in a match at The Show of Shows, but the bar fight ended his career before it took off.
A top AEW star just called one of his colleagues 'spoiled' and 'narcissistic' HERE.