#4 Dana Brooke
This is not a knock on Dana Brooke, as the chances are she may admit the same herself, but her call-up from NXT came too early in her career and at a time when WWE was jam-packing the roster with Superstars ahead of the 2016 brand split.
Since then, her realignment with Emma on the main roster was short-lived due to the Australian suffering an injury, while she played the role of Charlotte Flair’s protégé well but, for obvious reasons, was always going to be overshadowed by one of the best female performers WWE has ever seen.
It was teased a few months ago that Dana could join Titus Worldwide. Whether WWE picks that storyline up again is uncertain, but it would represent a good chance for her to break out of the shadow of other Superstars in her division.