#5 Zack Ryder
The Long Island Iced Z is one of the most perennially underused talents in wrestling. Every year he seems to lose more and more of his loyal fanbase while he remains mired in go-nowhere feuds with lower tier talent -- when he's used at all.
So far Zack hasn't given up, and neither have a majority of his fans, who would still love to see him go on a tear to the upper card, perhaps even the main event. The wily veteran and charismatic social media star could serve in this role well if given the chance.
Edited by Nishant Jayaram