#1 Bobby Lashley
One of the most baffling WWE runs of the last several years, when Bobby Lashley made his return to the company after more than 10 years he seemed destined for gigantic things. Pushed to the moon during his previous run, at the time he owed his lofty place on the roster due to how hugely muscled he was. However, in the years since then, Lashley had a stellar TNA/Impact Wrestling run in which he became a much better all-around performer and a marvelous villain.
Still as massive as he ever was and now able to portray a character with style, Lashley was ready to take the bull by the horns. Incredibly enough, however, since then he has been used so poorly that he is nowhere near the star that he was during his first WWE run or his time in TNA/Impact Wrestling.
The formerly intimidating Lashley has been underwhelmingly booked several times and that might lead him to call time on his WWE career again.