Season 3: John Morrison & Matt Capotelli (2003)
So seasons 1 and 2 may have been duds, but Season 3 delivered a bonafide star.
John Morrison would be one of the winners, and after some training, made a name for himself in WWE.
Will John Cena beat Ric Flair's record? A former WCW Champion thinks so HERE
Appearing in WWE from 2004-2011, Morrison would have great success, capturing the Intercontinental, Tag Team and ECW World titles, and has recently done huge things in Impact Wrestling.
A former Impact World Champion, Morrison seems to be in a great place in life, with his recent World title reign being the longest in seven years.
Unfortunately, Matt Capotelli's career would never really take off after his big win, as he suffered from Brain cancer in 2007, and was released in 2009.
In 2017, Cappitelli revealed he was battling grade IV glioblastoma multiforme and after ceasing treatment, died on June 28, 2018, aged 38.