Season 5: Andy Leavine (2011)
It was seven years between Tough Enough four and five and a lot had changed.
WWE had become a much bigger company and had shifted its focus, bringing in more and more 'indie darlings' such as CM Punk and Daniel Bryan.
Meet John Cena's dad HERE
Regardless, Andy Leavine won the 2011 series, but perhaps the Big Man would've been better never winning at all.
On the June 6, 2011, edition of RAW, Andy was announced the winner, and instantly had his big moment spoiled, with a swift slap from Vince McMahon.
One 'Stone Cold' Stunner later, and the so-called winner was already seen as a joke, returning to RAW for just one week before his release the next year.
Since WWE, Leavine has continued in wrestling, joining Puerto Rico's World Wrestling Council, where he is a former WWC Universal Heavyweight Champion.