Former WWE Superstar to return after 14 years and reunite with Judgment Day member? Potential twist explored

A WWE Superstar could return after 14 years to team up with Judgment Day member Carlito. The star in question is Chris Masters. He and Carlito had a fantastic tag team in 2006. Their biggest highlight was performing together at WrestleMania 22.

The Caribbean Bad Apple turned on The Masterpiece right after the biggest event of the year, leading to a match at Backlash that the former took home. Fast forward a year, Chris was released from the company but made a comeback in 2009. He was released once more in 2011, marking the end of his time with the promotion.

Since wrapping up his time in WWE, the 41-year-old has been making waves on the indie wrestling scene. He recently got everyone talking about a possible comeback by posting a video on his Instagram story. The clip featured him making his way to the ring with his classic WWE entrance music.

It could be a tease of him returning to WWE in 2025 after a 14-year break. The Stamford promotion could potentially reunite him with Carlito as part of The Judgment Day. The faction is dealing with some internal issues, and adding Masters could help out, considering his experience and physical presence that the group seems to be missing.

If he returns, it would mean a lot to fans who fondly remember his tag team days with Carlito. Joining forces again in The Judgment Day could reignite their chemistry and add an exciting new angle to the faction's storyline.

While the scenario is intriguing, at this time it's just conjecture. It's hard to tell if Masters' recent post was just a casual throwback or if it’s teasing something more significant.

---

Chris Masters could make his return at Royal Rumble 2025 and later team up with Judgment Day

The 30-man elimination match is known for its surprise comebacks. Many past names have made their presence felt over the years as surprise entrants.

The 2025 iteration could see Chris Masters gracing fans with his presence. If things work out, he could even be signed to a new contract, marking his third stint with the Sports Entertainment Juggernaut.

This might set the stage for a comeback with his former tag team buddy, sparking some great nostalgia for the longtime fans and boosting Judgment Day's impact. Masters could shine in the group thanks to his amazing physique, making the faction feel like a serious threat.