My Rating
This match is good. Really good. It's not the technical masterpiece I was expecting based on these men's reputation, but it was a classic of storytelling and the career vs. career stipulation ups the intensity for literally everyone in the match (it's also interesting that it's billed as "career vs. career," as if no longer wrestling in the World Wrestling Federation were the equivalent of no longer wrestling again, ever).
Heenan, as always, amplifies the in-ring action as only he could, and even Vince McMahon's stereotypically bombastic commentary doesn't detract.
Though the style these men worked made for a great contest, I can't give it a perfect 10/10 because of some of those sloppy spots; it took me out of the action a little to wonder how what a crisper, tighter contest between the two might have been.
Final score: 9/10
Meltzer says:
Dave gives this one ****, which is incredible for a "free" TV match at the time.