Round 2: Charisma
Where Shinsuke Nakamura lacks in his in-ring resume, he makes up for with his sheer physical charisma. His eccentric mannerisms capture and hold attention and he's still over despite the disappointments he's often run into.
New Champs in WWE! More RIGHT HERE
Seth Rollins falls in second place. Fans love him and want to get behind him. When he's playing the fiery, fighting babyface, everyone cheers for him to win.
Pete Dunne comes in third. While not the most charismatic guy around, he's still very over in NXT, and his mannerisms support his gritty "Bruiserweight" character excellently.
Ricochet was never known for his charisma. Athletic though he may be, he isn't as captivating as his peers when he isn't flying around the ring.
Verdict:
1st: Shinsuke Nakamura (+4 points)
2nd: Seth Rollins (+3 points)
3rd: Pete Dunne (+2 points)
4th: Ricochet (+1 point)