Conclusion
1st: Pete Dunne - 16 points
2nd: Seth Rollins - 15 points
3rd: Shinsuke Nakamura - 11 points
4th Ricochet - 8 points
There's a reason why Pete Dunne has reigned for nearly 500 days, and why Triple H is super high on him. He excels in nearly everything that makes for a great professional wrestler and his promo skills are good enough. His height is the only thing that would work against him, but in today's hyper-athletic age, that matters less than ever before.
Seth Rollins comes in a close second place. Like Pete Dunne, he either excels in every category or is good enough to not be lacking in any part of his game.
Shinsuke Nakamura's ring work has been weak, but his mannerisms and character make up for much of it, and the fact that he's as successful as he has been despite language issues is a testament to him.
Ricochet feels like he got the short straw in comparison to his peers. He too, is an excellent professional wrestler, only lacking in his game in comparison to his esteemed peers.
WWE's mid-card titles have arguably never had a stronger group of holders, though it would be nice to see Nakamura's reign booked better.