#4 Johnny Gargano vs. Aleister Black

An unfortunate injury derailed what seemed certain to be a match of the year contender at NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn 4. The yellow brand made the best of a bad situation, however, and spun Black's injury into a mystery angle as to who attacked him.
For months, everyone was a suspect. Finally, in October, the attacker was revealed as none other than Johnny Gargano, the once beloved hero of NXT who had become a grotesque parody of himself since his earlier feud with Andrade "Cien" Almas.
How Brock Lesnar ruined another wrestler's career - Watch Now!
Black vowed to take vengeance, but he did more than that in yet another classic match at NXT TakeOver: War Games II. He claimed to "absolve" Gargano of his sins there.
But Gargano wasn't interested in absolution and his obsessive, manic turn continues. Now even a reunion with Ciampa may be on the cards, with Black stuck in the middle, literally.
A top WWE star is missing in action