4: Cody Rhodes
The son of the son of a plumber was a solid wrestler in his time in WWE. A multiple tag team champion and Intercontinental Champion, Rhodes made his own way first as the son of Dusty Rhodes and then as a tag team partner with brother Goldust and later as Stardust. Rhodes had the look and the ability to be more. It never materialized.
Rhodes left WWE in the early part of this year due to being misused and a lack of push by management. He should have been a main-event star but instead, he was more a cartoon character than anything else.
Edited by Staff Editor