#3 Kane - 4 losses
Another in-ring veteran to feature on this list is The Big Red Machine, Kane. He has been away from WWE for a while now, and the probability that he competes at Extreme Rules: The Horror Show is very low.
His last appearance at this event had come in 2018, where he teamed up with Daniel Bryan to challenge The Bludgeon Brothers for the tag titles of the Blue brand. Unfortunately, Team Hell No lost that bout.
Kane's losses at WWE Extreme Rules
Talking about Kane's other appearances that ended in a losing cause, he had lost to Randy Orton at this PPV in 2012. The two Superstars had competed in a grueling Falls Count Anywhere match that lasted for 16 minutes and 45 seconds.
Like 2018, Team Hell No had teamed up at this event in 2013, where they defended their titles against The Shield. Roman Reigns and Seth Rollins defeated them to seize the gold. One year later, Kane challenged his former tag team partner Daniel Bryan for the WWE World Heavyweight Championship in an Extreme Rules match. Bryan retained his title using the Running Knee.