Jose Abreu was supposed to be the big piece that cemented the Houston Astros as legitimate repeat threats. Through the first portion of the season, Abreu has been a disaster. He's contributed -0.9 fWAR and is legitimately one of the worst starters in baseball in that regard.
His offense, which was a big draw for teams wanting to sign him, has been putrid. He's hitting at a 46 wRC+ clip, which is 54 points below the league average. He's slashing .218/.265/.261. His defense has been a surprisingly decent -1 defensive run saved thus far. Still, that's far from good.
Chandler Rome summed it up on Twitter:
"José Abreu, hitting cleanup for the 31st time in 36 games, grounded out with runners on first and second, one out and Shohei Ohtani on the ropes. Abreu has taken 42 plate appearances with runners in scoring position this season. He is 9-for-39 with five singles, no HR and 13 RBIs."
Abreu has been bad, but he's also getting a lot of opportunities. Dusty Baker hasn't dropped him from the lineup nor has he put him on the bench. Many fans are frustrated with both parties in this situation.
The Astros have limped out to a .500 record of 18-18, which is far from what was expected of the defending champions. Not many players are hitting well for Houston, but Abreu has certainly not helped them play any better.
How is Jose Abreu's predecessor doing in Miami?
No one would have ever thought that signing Jose Abreu and moving on from the abysmal Yuli Gurriel would backfire on the Astros, but it just might have. At least in the early going, it's seemingly looked like a mistake so far.
Gurriel hasn't been good either, but he's at least a neutral player with 0.0 fWAR for the Miami Marlins. His wRC+ of 91 is below average, but it's almost twice as productive as Abreu has been.
He's been slightly worse defensively with a -3 defensive runs saved, but the Astros would likely take the offensive production over a loss of defense.