“He’s done! Time to retire”; “Old man issues” — MLB fans react as Rangers place Max Scherzer on 15-day IL due to shoulder injury

Three-time Cy Young winner and active career-strikeout leader Max Scherzer was placed on the 15-day injured list on Friday because of right shoulder fatigue. The pitcher (2-4) has made only eight starts since his season debut on June 23 following offseason back surgery and then dealing with a nerve issue in his arm.

Scherzer has been an important piece for every side he’s played with, such as the World Series-winning Washington Nationals from 2019. The current Texas Rangers stint was meant to improve their rotation, but this injury dims his immediate contributions.

The fan reactions underscore the deep connection and high expectations surrounding Scherzer’s career, as well as the disappointment of seeing a legendary player struggle with injuries.

While the team has not provided a detailed timeline for his return, the news quickly spread across social media, with fans expressing their frustration and concern. Some fans took to X, formerly known as Twitter.

"Yeah he’s probably done. That’s completely ok if so though he’s had an amazing career," said one fan

"Him and trout need to retire. Probably degrom too," another fan added

"Might be time for Scherzer and Verlander to ride off into the sunset, congrats on great MLB careers," wrote one fan

“Simple, he’s done! Time to retire Max,” another fan bluntly stated

“Old man issues,” another fan quipped

The posts showed the widespread worry about whether Scherzer can recover and return to his dominant form.

Rangers Recall Walter Pennington to Replace Injured Max Scherzer

Texas Rangers have called up AAA Round Rock pitcher Walter Pennington after placing Scherzer on IL for 15 days because of a shoulder injury. Acquired from the Detroit Tigers for Michael Lorenzen during the trade deadline, Pennington is expected to help reinforce the Rangers pitching rotation while Scherzer is out.

Pennington has excelled in the minors, displaying command and a solid arsenal that made him an important acquisition for Texas. This promotion is vital for Texas as it tries to hold on to its edge in AL West while dealing with major injuries.

Since his arrival, three-time Cy Young winner Scherzer has been a key member of the Rangers’ pitching staff. The team’s fortunes will be damaged by his departure; however, Pennington is seen as someone who would offer stability and productive innings.

The big league team gets an extra arm in 27-year-old Pennington, and how he performs will be something to watch, as he is expected to fill in for one of the most experienced pitchers ever in baseball.