Which Guardians players have also played for the Pirates? MLB Immaculate Grid Answers October 2

The MLB Immaculate Grid for October 2 features two teams: the Cleveland Guardians and Pittsburgh Pirates. They have had a few players crossover from team to team during their histories, even though they play in complete opposite leagues. There are a total of 200 possible answers. Fortunately, you need only name one of them.

First baseman Josh Bell is a perfect example for this prompt. He was a member of the Pirates from 2016 to 2020. In 2023, the Guardians signed him to add some power to their lineup. He was used by 21% of players at the time of writing.

---

MLB Immaculate Grid Answers October 2: Which Guardians players have also played for the Pirates?

Below are some other players who played for both the teams during their careers:

• John Axford (2014 with both teams)
• Bert Blyleven (1981-1985 with CLE, 1978-1980 with PIT)
• Melky Cabrera (2018 with CLE, 2019 with PIT)
• Yu Chang (2019-2022 with CLE, 2022 with PIT)

Outfielder Greg Allen has become a journeyman. He was on the New York Yankees this season, but he played for both these squads. In 2022, he was on the Pirates. From 2017-2020, he was a Guardians (Indians at the time) outfielder.

Greg Allen played for the Pirates and Guardians

Another outfielder, Rajai Davis, did this. In 2006 and 2007, he was a member of the Pirates. In 2016, 2017 and 2018, he was part of the Guardians franchise, including their trip to the World Series.

Make sure you check out our other MLB Immaculate Grid articles. This one and the others like it can and will help you answer every single prompt every single day. They may even improve your rarity score.