NHL Rumors: Pittsburgh Penguins concerned about $92,000,000 star's 'nonchalant attitude'

The Pittsburgh Penguins brought in Erik Karlsson who carries a big $92 million contract, hoping for a boost on both ends of the ice. Known for his offensive skills, Karlsson showed his scoring touch with a goal and an assist against the Washington Capitals on Saturday.

It marked his second multi-point game of the season, with his goal coming just minutes into the game. However, even with strong offensive performances, there are concerns within the team about his defensive play.

The Athletic's Josh Yohe said that the Penguins are worried that Karlsson’s defensive style will leave them vulnerable.

"The (Penguins) organization remains concerned about his game, his nonchalant attitude and his contract." Yohe wrote on Monday.

Karlsson struggles when defending against left-wing rushes, especially on his right side. In several games, he’s been caught turning away from attackers on his right or heading toward the puck carrier rather than covering his man. This has allowed opposing teams to take advantage of his positioning, making it easier to attack the Penguins.

Yohe used the game against the Carolina Hurricanes as an example, where Karlsson missed several defensive assignments along the left wing. In another game against Vancouver, Daniel Sprong got around Karlsson to set up a goal. Karlsson’s overall stats reflect this imbalance: 10 points and a minus-7 rating over 16 games. According to Yohe, that’s unusual for a player who logs more than 20 minutes per game.

Karlsson is popular with his teammates, and his public comments suggest he believes he’s playing well. However, Yohe suggests this attitude is concerning.

"The organization is concerned that Karlsson is unlikely to improve, and team sources are not thrilled with Karlsson’s public comments suggesting he’s playing well." Yohe wrote.

With the season shifting to an intense phase, Karlsson needs to step up for the Pittsburgh Penguins to avoid all the questions.

---

Eric Karlsson's response to Pittsburgh Penguins HC and the expectations attached to his big contract

Pittsburgh Penguins coach Mike Sullivan recently called for more discipline and effort, which may have been aimed at Eric Karlsson. While Karlsson’s response in the next game was positive, it’s unclear if this change will stick.

Karlsson’s $92 million contract adds to the challenge. With so much money invested, the Penguins are limited in ways to strengthen their defense. Karlsson's contract will run till the 2026-27 season, so he has two more years after this season. With a cap hit of $11,500,000 per season, the Pittsburgh Penguins need Karlsson to be a steady presence on both offense and defense.