#3 Lex Luger
Lex Luger is a fan favourite name, especially as he was to become the face of the company when Hulk Hogan left WWE. The man was considered as a top star, and his association with Four Horsemen speaks volumes about the star he was. He was supposed to carry 'The Lex Express' across the country during the summer of '93.
After he left WWE(then WWF), he made an appearance at WCW's show the next day, and that left the WWE Universe as well as wrestling fans buzzing. The wrestler was also involved in issues pertaining to Miss Elizabeth who was the manager and wife of Macho Man Randy Savage.
A former WWE writer just went after JBL for his comments HERE
This along with his issues with drugs or steroids is a major reason why he isn't inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame, and the way situations stand right now, it seems difficult, that he would make it through that long list of deserving superstars.