5 most overrated players in Raiders history ft. Derek Carr 

#3) Charlie Garner

NFL: USA TODAY Sports-Archive

Was Charlie Garner one of the best dual-threat running backs at the turn of the millennium? By the time he reached his first Pro Bowl with the San Francisco 49ers across the Bay, he had a strong case.

But his stint with the Raiders represents an interesting dynamic. Despite being a versatile weapon (900 yards both rushing and receiving in 2002), he was a largely anonymous presence when compared to Hall of Famers Tim Brown and Jerry Rice.