NFL analyst draws comparison between Tyreek Hill and Andre Johnson after Dolphins WR tapped out of fourth quarter

NFL analyst Steve Smith Sr. drew a parallel between Tyreek Hill's fourth-quarter exit and former NFL wideout Andre Johnson's past uncertainties. Both star receivers faced pivotal moments that questioned their futures with their respective teams.

Hill, an eight-time Pro Bowl receiver, pulled himself out during the Dolphins' season finale against the Jets on Sunday. Johnson, the Texans' all-time leader with 1,012 receptions and 13,597 yards, eventually sought a trade after years of offensive struggles.

Speaking on "89" on Wednesday, Steve Smith Sr. recalled Johnson's candid moment during a charitable event. The memory resurfaced as Tyreek Hill's departure and postgame comments sparked discussions about his future in Miami.

"Remember when Andre Johnson said this to me once? He was making a massive donation to a women's shelter in Houston. He just says, 'I don't know if this is supposed to be the place for me anymore.' And Dre was just like, he didn't know if he wanted to be in Houston anymore," Smith said.

Hill's situation mirrors Johnson's. After Miami's 32-20 loss eliminated them from playoff contention, Hill stated:

"I'm out, bro. It was great playing here, but, at the end of the day, I've gotta do what's best for my career."

This marked Hill's first missed playoffs in nine seasons.

Tyreek Hill is not asking for a trade

Syndication: The Record - Source: Imagn

Smith highlighted how elite players often internalize their struggles before speaking out. Dolphins coach Mike McDaniel addressed Hill's actions in an hour-long meeting, calling them "not acceptable" and demanding accountability.

Tyreek Hill's numbers dropped significantly in 2024, recording 81 catches for 959 yards and six touchdowns. Quarterback Tua Tagovailoa's six-game absence due to concussion and hip injuries affected the offense's productivity. Despite Hill's restructured three-year, $90 million contract through 2026, trade speculation has emerged.

Like Johnson before him, who spent 14 seasons in Houston before joining the Colts in 2015, Hill faces a crossroads. Several playoff teams could benefit from his talents. The Chargers boast $74.4 million in cap space, while the Commanders have $102.5 million available.

Though Miami GM Chris Grier denied any trade requests, the parallels between Hill and Johnson's situations suggest star receivers' frustrations can reshape their careers. As Miami evaluates its 8-9 season, Hill's future remains uncertain.