"We saw Zach Wilson do this": Fans unfazed by J.J. McCarthy's 65-yard throw at Michigan pro-day

"We saw Zach Wilson do this": Fans unfazed by J.J. McCarthy
"We saw Zach Wilson do this": Fans unfazed by J.J. McCarthy's 65-yard throw at Michigan pro-day

J.J. McCarthy threw a 65-yarder during Michigan's Pro Day and all that happened is he ended up being compared to Zach Wilson. At least, that is the impression one got from social media.

The Jets quarterback famously threw a deep ball during his time in front of the scouts and it is widely believed that it convinced the franchise to draft him No. 2 overall. To say that it has turned out the way New York fans would have hoped for is an understatement.

He has never managed to establish himself as an NFL-caliber quarterback, never mind one worthy of such a high pick. The Jets had to go and get Aaron Rodgers at nearly 40 years old because Zach Wilson performed so poorly. Right now, there is no trade market for him either, or so it seems. Even the franchise's last bust, Sam Darnold found willing trade partners and has an NFL career.

That is why J.J. McCarthy is also being doubted and one could say unfairly. There is no guarantee of success but just because the National Championship-winning quarterback can throw a deep ball like his Jets counterpart does not mean he will be a bust.

Looking to predict NFL playoff Scenarios? Try our NFL Playoff Predictor for real-time simulations and stay ahead of the game!

But social media has never been a place for nuance. Fans took to X, formerly Twitter, to compare J.J. McCarthy to Zach Wilson.

Here is a selection of some of the responses on X:

J.J. McCarthy not the only 2024 NFL draft QB prospect getting dragged because of Zach Wilson

Zach Wilson has burned the Jets so badly that a great throw is being characterized as an indication that a player will be a bust. And J.J. McCarthy is not the only one who is facing this situation.

Joe Milton had a similarly great deep throw during the NFL Combine. Instead of it helping his draft stock climb, fans were all over him saying that he would be the next flop like the Jets quarterback.

It seems as if a great throw during the Combine or the Pro Day is an albatross around the neck of rookie prospects. But it should not be, because for every Zach Wilson, there are success stories like Patrick Mahomes as well, who made such throws look effortless. And nobody can accuse the Kansas City Chiefs star of being even close to a bust. He is in rather in the GOAT conversation.

What did you make of J.J. McCarthy's Pro Day showing? Where do you think he will get drafted? Let us know your thoughts in the comments section below.

New York Jets Nation! Check out the latest Jets Schedule and dive into the New York Jets Depth Chart for NFL Season 2024-25.

Quick Links

Edited by Rit Nanda
Sportskeeda logo
Close menu
WWE
WWE
NBA
NBA
NFL
NFL
MMA
MMA
Tennis
Tennis
NHL
NHL
Golf
Golf
MLB
MLB
Soccer
Soccer
F1
F1
WNBA
WNBA
More
More
bell-icon Manage notifications