Top 10 NFL Draft Busts

Courtney Brown After is taken off-field after an injury

32 Teams. 7 Rounds. 224 Young Men just out of colleges are about to become players in theNational Football League.Fates are decided. Dynasties are born. Of course I am talking aboutDRAFT DAY.2015 Draft Day is only two days away.Teams are given the chance to seriously revamp their roster and hopefully contend for a super bowl title in the next few seasons. The magnitude of their decisions could effect the future of careers and families, and can alter the trajectory of the league. With so much pressure placed on the draft, there is a growing need for the management of teams to get decisions correct. Sometimes brilliant decisions aremade, while other times there can be duds. Here is a list of the latter

#10 Courtney Brown

Courtney Brown After is taken off-field after an injury

Looking to predict NFL playoff Scenarios? Try our NFL Playoff Predictor for real-time simulations and stay ahead of the game!

Name Courtney Brown
Year2000
TeamCleveland Browns
PickNo. 1 Overall

As elected number one overall in the 2000 NFL draft, Brown was always injury plagued. He played bits and pieces of five seasons for Cleveland but could not last beyond that. During that time he posted utterly underwhelming numbers and his team did not progress in the standings.

After four years with the Browns, he moved to Denver, but only played one season before retiring in 2005.

#9 Akili Smith

Akili Smith only started in 17 games and throw just 5 touch-down passes
Name Akili Smith
Year1999
Team Cincinnati Bengals
PickNo. 3 overall

Smith was an example of someone who was largely unproven in college. After playing his first two seasons at a San Diego community college, he had one great season at Oregon before being drafted third overall by the Cincinnati Bengals.

To add insult to injury, before the draft that year, the Bengals were offered nine draft picks from the New Orleans Saints in order to get that third pick.

#8 Todd Blackledge

He was picked ahead of Hall of Famers like Dan Marino and Jim Kelly
Name Todd Blackledge
Year1983
Team Kansas City Chiefs
PickNo. 7 Overall

The 1983 draft was legendary for producing some of the greatest quarterbacks of all-time. Among them were John Elway, Dan Marino, and Jim Kelly.

Not among them was Todd Blackledge.

The Kansas City Chiefs picked Blackledge when they still had the chance of getting Marino or Kelly. But if it is any consolation for him, Blackledge was the last quarterback that was drafted by Kansas City that won a game with the franchise until 2014.

#7 Rick Mirer

He played for Bears,Packers,Jets,49’ers,Raiders and Lions but was never able to justify high pick
Name Rick Mirrer
Year1993
TeamSeattle Seahawks
PickNo. 2 Overall

Initially, Rick Mirer wasn’t a bust at all. During his first season with Seattle, Mirer set rookie records for yards and completions. He also started in every regular season game for the Seahawks. It wasn’t until his second and third years that Mirer experienced a rapid decline. He was subsequently traded to Chicago for a draft pick. Mirer's struggles as quarterback came from what was perceived as subpar football intelligence and inability to throw to his left. Despite a good first season with the Seahawks, in a 12-year career, Mirer never justified being a top draft pick after being hyped as "the next Joe Montana".

#6 Tim Couch

He was promising but suffered many injuries in his time with Browns due to its inexperienced offensive line
NameTim Couch
Year1999
TeamCleveland Browns
PickNo. 1 Overall

Remember how Cleveland drafted Courtney Brown in 2000? Well, the damage was done the year before. With the number one pick in 1999, the Browns selected Tim Couch, even though Donovan McNabb was very available.

Plagued by injuries, and affected by the fact that Cleveland gave him zero offensive weapons, Couch could never get a full season under his belt. Another bust in a long list of Cleveland Brown drafting failures, he was dropped after five seasons.

#5 Todd Marinovich

His NFL career was cut short due to his drug addiction and parties
Name Todd Marinovich
Year1991
TeamOakland Raiders
PickNo. 24 Overall

Marinovich had an unhappy, abusive childhood where his father was overly intense and started his athletic training from the time Todd was an infant.

By the time he reached college, Todd became rebellious, partaking in the drug and alcohol party culture at college. This led to him having a tumultuous life and career.

He was drafted by Al Davis and the Raiders, but fizzled out of the league after repeated drug allegations and poor play.

#4 Blair Thomas

He was the leading NFL rookies in yards-per-carry in 1991
NameBlair Thomas
Year1990
TeamNew York Jets
PickNo. 2 Overall

His NFL career started out well, as he lead rookies in yards per carry and total yardage. Soon after that, however, he experienced a number of debilitating injuries that slowed down his career.

Thomas was out by the mid 1990s. Thomas was one of several former Penn State running backs to have a lackluster pro career after performing well at the university.

#3 Andre Ware

He was inducted into the College Football Hall of Fame in 2004
NameAndre Ware
Year1990
TeamDetroit Lions
PickNo. 7 Overall

Andre Ware was exciting to watch when he played his college ball. Winning the Heisman trophy at Houston, Ware looked like a gifted player who could go on to a solid pro career. After he was drafted by the Detroit Lions, he did not do much at all.

For most of his career, Ware was very low on the team’s depth chart (often second or third). By 1993, Andre Ware had played in his final NFL game.

#2 Lawrence Phillips

He is currently serving 7 years in prison and once it completes, he has his hands full with another term of 25 years for domestic assault on his girlfriend
Name Lawrence Phillips
Year1996
TeamSt. Louis Rams
PickNo. 6 Overall

Phillips is living proof of how important it is to factor in a player’s character when it comes to drafting. After having already been convicted of abusing his girlfriend while in college at Nebraska, Phillips was known to be volatile and exercise a rough temper.

A major misstep the Rams made was when they elected to dump Jerome Bettis in order to make roster space for Phillips.

More recently, in prison, he is suspected to have killed a cell-mate.

#1 Ryan Leaf

Ryan Leaf was recently released from prison on parole
Name Ryan Leaf
Year1998
TeamSan Diego Chargers
PickNo. 2 Overall

Leaf is known in most circles to be the worst player ever drafted in NFL history, based on his predicted level of potential by “experts.” Throughout his short career, Leaf blew up at media people, partied extensively, and never got it done on the field.

The Chargers had given away a number of crucial draft picks to the Arizona Cardinals as well as Pro Bowl defender Eric Metcalf. Within a few seasons Ryan Leaf was out of football for good.

Detroit Lions Fans! Check out the latest Lions Schedule and dive into the Detroit Lions Depth Chart for NFL Season 2024-25.

Quick Links

Edited by Staff Editor
Sportskeeda logo
Close menu
WWE
WWE
NBA
NBA
NFL
NFL
MMA
MMA
Tennis
Tennis
NHL
NHL
Golf
Golf
MLB
MLB
Soccer
Soccer
F1
F1
WNBA
WNBA
More
More
bell-icon Manage notifications